Vutulaki wrote:Anastasios wrote: The muscle doesn't start rebuilding itself immediately so the reparation process hasn't even started when you leave the gym. It is the protein you have over the next few days that repair the muscle to grow it bigger.
This is a good point, so you would agree that the "golden hour" which is said to be 5 hours post workout is bullshit? Personally based on how I feel nothing scientific but I feel like sleep is what kicks off the process of repair more than ingesting protein but of course the immune system needs the protein to repair.
Speaking of science a lot of the "scientific" excerise peer reviewed studies that guys like Mike Israetal cite seem dubious. Often youll look them up and the both the number of participants IE = <50 or the fact that they are either 35 untrained college students or fucking cancer patients is shit. Give us studies on 30,000 people over a longer time trame. Im sure its a matter of time and cost but still its hard to take that shit seriously
I like Israetels videos but he tailor makes his content for an audience. As with everyone else like him, when selling a business model, all parts have to be aligned both in concept and with what other content creators say. Being huge on youtube and selling the idea that post workout nutrition is not any more important than nutrition throughout the day is going against the stream. That in itself would evoke outcry from all other content creators lol.
On the other hand some elite bodybuilding coaches have debated this on youtube, the videos are not so popular though. IIRC Dave Palumbo and Milos Sarcev have debated this on Palumbos channel. Sarcev argument is that insulin pre workout makes you absorb even more nutrients in to muscle, aiding training and post workout recovery. IIRC Palumbo says there might be some science that makes this a good idea but real world results are not noticeable, and he advises a long acting insulin. Beware though, this is advanced stuff, the reason he says insulin is for bodybuilders of advanced size who are eating so much that their natural insulin production is not enough to maintain normal blood sugar levels. So this nit picking nutrition timing is not worth the effort IMO. We are not training for the Olympia.
